News

Keep up to date
Get the latest Conservative news sent straight to you

Find a blog

or

or

The Blue Blog

A lesson for the UK from Ireland's recent economic experience

The Rt Hon The Lord Trimble , Saturday, January 10 2009

Lord Trimble

There is a great lesson for the United Kingdom to learn from Ireland's recent economic experience.  The high growth rates that led to the term "The Celtic Tiger" had passed their peak when Ireland decided to enter the Euro.  But some commentators were then saying entry would be bad because it would result in reduced interest rates at a time when rates should increase to dampen inflationary tendencies arising from that growth.  I remember putting that point to a senior Irish official, who assured me of his confidence that Europe would respond if there was a crisis.

There was, however, no response to the subsequent significant increase in inflation.  Nor was there a response when the appreciation of the Euro priced Irish goods out of their two main export markets - the UK and the US.  These factors were clearly pushing the Irish economy into recession even before the referendum on the Lisbon constitution. But there has been no understanding in Brussels of the economic reasons for the Irish disgruntlement with Europe.

For us it underlines the economic case against the Euro.  The United Kingdom is one of the largest economies in the world.  Insofar as an economy can be managed, we need to have those levers of power under our control.  Above all, if our economy has been mismanaged, we need to be able to turn out the rascals responsible. 

These days, I am not so concerned with the opinion polls.  But I am very anxious to have a real poll.  Gordon Brown has done enormous damage to our economy.  This crisis is largely home grown and particularly his responsibility.  I want to see this man out of office before he does even more damage.  In this New Year we should be pressing for new people to take over, rather than have those who cannot see, let alone admit, their mistakes go on to make even more mistakes.

( 3 comments )

Comment on this blog

Comment by Seymour Major on Jan 10 2009, 16:27

Lord Trimble,

I'm not a journalist by I was saying exactly what the commentators said when Ireland joined the Euro. In joining the Euro, they were giving up their main monetary control over inflation. I told my Irish friends and neighbours that it would one day end in tears.
The Labour Government had the ability to control inflation. It failed to do so. Eyebrows may be raised by some reading this but I am not talking about the consumer price index. I am talking about Land inflation, particularly in relation to homes. If monetary administration had been tighter, Land inflation would not have gone out of control and excess debt (which has been identified as the main cause of the banking crisis) would not have occurred. It is also correct to say that there could have been better regulation of the financial system but who can now argue that Gordon Brown's inflation targets to the Bank of England were not flawed?
As for the Republic of Ireland, they find themselves similarlly damaged by the debt crisis but there is another crucial difference. Being in the Euro, their export businesses are now very uncompetitive. In the UK, at least, the lower pound enables our export companies to compete.

Comment by David Waddell on Jan 11 2009, 14:37

It struck me, as we in the UK were debating the euro back in 2000/1, that an important reason for staying out of the currency was this: once we voted to adopt it, we could not easily withdraw. For as long as the debate raged on the substantive arguments, it seemed crazy to say yes. If we ever should say yes, it should only be after the argument had been made convincingly and overwhelmingly accepted.It seems now the answer is much clearer. Adopting the euro would have been a grave error. Just as well we didn't then! As Jeff Randall reported in the Daily Telegraph last week, Gordon Brown played a blinder on that one. For that, if not much else, he deserves credit.

Comment by ZoonPol on Jan 12 2009, 11:03

The Lisburn Constitution?
The European Constitution failed whereas the Reform Treaty signed in Lisbon does what it says on the tin.

Comment

You must Login or Register to add a comment.